Follow the Recipe | God’s Way Is the Best Way | Object Lesson
Needed Items
- Printed chocolate-chip cookie recipe
- Measuring cups and measuring spoons
- Two mixing bowls
- Mixing spoons
- Pretend ingredients or sealed containers representing flour, sugar, chocolate chips, vanilla, salt, and other recipe ingredients
- Container labeled “Powdered Sugar”
- Container labeled “Syrup”
- Container labeled “Sprinkles”
- Two pre-prepared dough samples, one representing properly mixed cookie dough and another representing a sticky, poorly mixed mess
- Optional separately baked chocolate-chip cookies for serving
- Bible
Preparation
Before class, prepare two cookie-making stations. One station will represent following a recipe carefully, while the other will represent someone who decides to make cookies without following the instructions.
Print an actual chocolate-chip cookie recipe and place it at the first station along with measuring cups, measuring spoons, and the pretend or sealed ingredients. At the second station, arrange ingredients representing some of the unusual substitutions Delaney will make.
Prepare two samples ahead of time. One should look like properly mixed chocolate-chip cookie dough, while the other should resemble a sticky, unappetizing mess. These are demonstration samples only and should not be eaten. You can use pretend dough or other suitable materials to create the appearance without using raw eggs or other ingredients that would create unnecessary food safety concerns.
If you decide to serve cookies afterward, prepare them separately using a proper recipe. Check ingredient labels and known food allergies before serving.
This demonstration is based on a video featuring Delaney and Brianna attempting to make Grandma Sweet Tea’s famous chocolate-chip cookies. You can show the video if available or recreate the activity with two teachers or volunteers. The dialogue can be adapted to fit your classroom.
Object Lesson
Begin by explaining that Grandma Sweet Tea makes some amazing chocolate-chip cookies. In fact, her cookies are so good that Delaney and Brianna have decided to try making them themselves.
There is just one problem. Brianna plans to follow Grandma Sweet Tea’s recipe, but Delaney thinks she can figure it out on her own.
Have Brianna begin by looking over the printed recipe. She should carefully measure each pretend ingredient before adding it to her mixing bowl. Point out how she checks the instructions to make sure she uses the correct ingredients and amounts.
Meanwhile, have Delaney confidently announce that she doesn’t need a recipe. After all, how hard could making chocolate-chip cookies really be?
Allow Delaney to begin adding ingredients to her bowl without measuring anything. When the recipe calls for flour, have her reach for the container labeled powdered sugar instead. She can reason that it looks close enough and should make the cookies even sweeter.
When the recipe calls for vanilla, have Delaney grab the syrup. She can explain that syrup is sweet, so it should work just as well.
Next comes the salt. Rather than carefully measuring the small amount called for in the recipe, Delaney decides that a generous amount would probably make the cookies taste even better.
Finally, have her add plenty of sprinkles. After all, everything is better with sprinkles!
Throughout the demonstration, allow Brianna to continue calmly following the recipe while Delaney becomes increasingly confident in her unusual decisions. Encourage some humor as Delaney insists that her cookies are going to be amazing.
Once both teachers have finished pretending to mix their ingredients, bring out the two pre-prepared samples.
Show the children the properly mixed dough first. Explain that this represents what Brianna made by carefully following Grandma Sweet Tea’s instructions.
Next, reveal Delaney’s sticky mess.
Allow the children to react and compare the two samples. Ask which one looks more like chocolate-chip cookie dough and why they think the results are so different.
Point out that both girls started with the same goal. They both wanted to make Grandma Sweet Tea’s delicious cookies. The difference was that Brianna followed the instructions, while Delaney decided to do things her own way.
Explain that Delaney might have had some creative ideas, but substituting ingredients and ignoring measurements didn’t produce the cookies she wanted.
Bible Connection
Use the demonstration to introduce an important lesson about following God’s instructions.
Explain that many people want God’s blessings and want to make it to Heaven, but not everyone wants to follow what God has told us in His Word. Some people decide they can make up their own way of living for God.
They might think certain parts of Scripture aren’t important or that they can leave out something God has commanded. But just as Grandma Sweet Tea knew how her cookies were supposed to be made, God knows what is best for us.
Read Isaiah 55:8–9: “For my thoughts are not your thoughts, neither are your ways my ways, saith the LORD. For as the heavens are higher than the earth, so are my ways higher than your ways, and my thoughts than your thoughts.”
Explain that God sees and understands things we cannot. His wisdom is far greater than ours, which is why we should trust His Word rather than assume our own ideas are always better.
Return to the printed recipe and remind the children that Brianna didn’t have to guess what ingredients to use. She had clear instructions right in front of her.
In a much more important way, God has given us His Word to teach us how to live and how to respond to the Gospel.
Read Acts 2:38: “Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.”
Explain that when the people asked Peter what they should do, he gave them God’s instructions. He told them to repent, be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.
Take a moment to explain each part in language the children can understand. Repentance means turning away from sin and turning toward God. Baptism in Jesus’ name means being immersed in water for the remission of sins. Receiving the Holy Ghost means receiving God’s Spirit.
Remind the children that these instructions are not something we should change simply because we think we have a better idea.
However, make sure they understand that living for God is not like following a recipe that guarantees a perfect batch of cookies. Salvation is not something we manufacture by completing a list of ingredients, and obeying God does not mean we will never experience problems or disappointments.
The recipe is simply an illustration to help us remember that God’s instructions matter and His wisdom is greater than ours.
Teacher Follow-Up
Bring the two dough samples back into view and ask the children to explain what happened during the demonstration. Help them identify the differences between Brianna’s approach and Delaney’s approach.
Ask a few questions to reinforce the lesson:
- Why did Brianna use measuring cups and follow the printed recipe?
- What happened when Delaney started replacing ingredients with whatever she wanted?
- Why do you think God gave us instructions in the Bible?
- What does Isaiah 55:8–9 teach us about God’s wisdom compared to our own?
- What did Peter tell the people to do in Acts 2:38?
- What is one way we can follow God’s Word instead of simply doing whatever we want?
Explain that sometimes God’s instructions may not make sense to us right away. We might not understand why something matters or why God asks us to do things a certain way. That doesn’t mean His instructions are wrong. It means we still have things to learn.
Encourage the children to ask questions, study their Bibles, and seek help from parents, pastors, and teachers when they don’t understand something in Scripture.
Remind them that God’s Word is not meant to be ignored or rewritten to fit our preferences. It teaches us who God is, how to respond to Him, and how to live in a way that pleases Him.
Finish by pointing to the printed recipe and the two dough samples one final time. Reinforce the main point that God’s way is always better than trying to make up our own way. We can trust His Word because His wisdom is greater than ours.
